Showing posts with label Stagecoach. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stagecoach. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 31, 2026

News: Public sector puts £100m towards depots and buses in South Yorkshire

By

Private sector operators that run South Yorkshire bus services described by the local mayor as being in a "spiral of decline," look set for a multimillion pound windfall as the public sector acquires depots and vehicles as part of bus franchising.

Last year South Yorkshire’s Mayor, Oliver Coppard, took a once in a generation decision to bring buses back under public control in South Yorkshire in the biggest shake up of the bus network since the 1980s.

Under bus franchising, the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) will take control of the bus network including depots, bus fleets, routes, timetables, service standards, tickets and fares.

The authority announced this month that it had secured the purchase of five depots from private bus operators.

The depots at Olive Grove, Ecclesfield and Holbrook in Sheffield, Rawmarsh in Rotherham, Wakefield Road in Barnsley, along with the already publicly owned Leger Way depot in Doncaster, form the operational backbone of South Yorkshire’s bus network.

Under the agreement, First Bus and Stagecoach will lease the depots back from SYMCA.

No figures were included in the announcement but earlier this month the authority published that a delegated decision had been made: "to grant award of £100m towards Bus Franchising Works for acquisition of depots and purchase of vehicles."

SYMCA had previously appointed commercial property firm, Sanderson Weatherall, to value the depots.

The funding is set to come from government funding pots given to devolved areas such as the City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement and Transport for City Regions.

With £1.5 billion confirmed for South Yorkshire in 2025, £350m will be set aside to reform South Yorkshire’s buses, with franchised buses begining in 2027 with Doncaster and most of Sheffield, followed by Barnsley and Rotherham in 2028 (pushed back from an original target of 2027), with the remaining areas of Sheffield completing the move to public control in 2029.

Advertisement
South Yorkshire’s Mayor Oliver Coppard said: “This is a significant moment for South Yorkshire. Bringing every depot into public ownership well in advance of bus franchising means we’re putting real foundations in place for a network that is reliable, affordable and works for all of us. It’s exactly what taking back control of our public transport looks like. As we roll out the South Yorkshire People’s Network, we’re creating one clearer, simpler and more connected transport system, and these depots will be right at the heart of making that happen.”

Matt Kitchin, Managing Director of Stagecoach Yorkshire, which operates the Rawmnarsh depot in Rotherham, said: “We are very pleased to be working with Mayor Coppard to complete the transition of depots to public ownership, in a way that best avoids disruption for our loyal customers and colleagues across the region.

“As the operator of the largest zero-emission electric bus fleet in the UK, we are looking forward to contributing our extensive expertise in electrifying depots and introducing new electric fleets to the South Yorkshire bus network.

“Our experience has shown that our customers and colleagues hugely appreciate electric vehicles as they're quieter, smoother and more reliable, helping local people to get to work, access services, and to meet friends and family, and so we are excited to work in partnership to provide the best services for South Yorkshire.”

The mayor has previously described local bus services as a "failed experiment of the privatisation of our bus network that was started in the 1980s." The bus market in South Yorkshire has been experiencing a continuous cycle of decline while its reliance on public funding to sustain bus service levels has been increasing. Over the past decade, bus mileage declined by 42%.

Just last week, SYMCA released details that a "significant number" of commercial bus services have been registered for reduction or withdrawal by operators in May. A £1,278,100 funding package has been signed off to ensure all services indicated are retained for a period until July 25 2026. SYMCA said that the withdrawals and reductions would "have an impact on users and also creates a threat to the ability for SYMCA to transition to a franchised network based on the current level of service."

As part of the deal, the Rawmarsh depot formerly owned by Stagecoach will get a new office building to replace temporary structures. The other bus depot in Rotherham was in public sector ownership but SYMCA decided to sell it in 2022. The Midland Road depot has been demolished and the site is being transformed into a housing estate.

Images: Google Maps

Read more...

Tuesday, January 28, 2025

News: New electric buses having to return to depot on Rotherham routes

By

Further delays to a new charging system at Rotherham bus station has led to an inefficient schedule where new electric buses have to return to the depot to charge up.

Rothbiz revealed first that a multimillion pound transport project to introduce state-of-the-art electric buses on to South Yorkshire's roads had got off to a spluttering start with a diesel generator being used last year to charge up their batteries in Rotherham.

The installation of pantograph chargers at Rotherham Interchange, which underwent a £12m refurb five years ago, has still not taken place.

£61,950 is now having to be found to cover the costs incurred by bus operators caused by the delays.

Government funding was secured by the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) for the Zero Emission Bus Regional Areas (ZEBRA) scheme and the first fleet of 23 zero emission electric buses arrived in the region at the start of 2024.

The brand-new electric Yutong buses have since introduced on the region’s bus network, featuring on the 22x and 221 routes which connect the Dearne Valley across Rotherham, Barnsley and Doncaster.

The bid included 23 x 150kW depot chargers for Stagecoach's Rawmarsh depot purchased by Stagecoach and 2 x 300kW opportunity charging units for routes located at Rotherham Interchange to be owned and purchased by SYMCA.

Partners have previously expressed frustration with delays at Northern Powergrid in upgrading the substation at Rotherham Interchange and now Stagecoach are set to receive funding from SYMCA.

Advertisement
An update states: "SYMCA has been working with Arup, Swarco and Northern PowerGrid to deliver the pantograph charging infrastructure at RTI [Rotherham Interchange]. Unfortunately, delays to the implementation of a new substation at the interchange has meant that the pantographs are not yet in operation, and they are unlikely to be in operation until the end of this financial year (current forecast).

"Rather than reduce service levels and provide a poorer service for customers, including reputational risk for SYMCA, Stagecoach have implemented an inefficient vehicle schedule to allow charging at the depot.

"Stagecoach have provided details that without the pantograph chargers a number of buses have to be returned to depot. This requires additional staff time as a direct result of the delays to the SYMCA project."

SYMCA's Executive Director of Transport has approved the extra £61,950.

For the project overall, DfT contributed £8,351,721 and SYMCA contributed £2,683,051 of their City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) provided by Government. Stagecoach is contributing around £4m.

Images: eVolt

Read more...

Wednesday, January 17, 2024

News: Work starts as Rotherham leads charge for electric buses

By

Work has started at a depot in Rotherham to bring the first fleet of zero emission electric buses to South Yorkshire as part of a partnership between Stagecoach and South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA).

Electrification work has begun at the Rawmarsh depot ahead of the arrival of the first fleet of 23 zero emission electric buses to arrive in the region.

The brand-new electric Yutong buses will be introduced on the region’s bus network in the spring and will feature on the 22x and 221 routes which connect the Dearne Valley across Rotherham, Barnsley and Doncaster.

The project is part of South Yorkshire’s first successful bid for Zero Emission Bus Regional Area funding (ZEBRA) from the Department for Transport (DfT) in partnership with South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) and Stagecoach.

DfT contributed £8,351,721 as part of our winning ZEBRA bid and SYMCA also contributed £2,683,051 of their City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement (CRSTS) provided by Government.

The infrastructure needed to charge and maintain the electric buses also reflects a major £2.5m investment in the Rawmarsh depot.

The contractor, EO, will install the 23 output chargers as well as two mobile workshop chargers at the depot which will facilitate the running of the zero-emission fleet.

Advertisement
South Yorkshire’s Mayor, Oliver Coppard, said: “We think around 200,000 people in South Yorkshire live in areas vulnerable to air pollution, and 1 in 20 deaths here are related to poor air quality. That’s a challenge we simply have to address, and why we need to get cleaner, greener vehicles of all sorts on our roads.

“To meet that goal we’ve funded electric bus projects that are underway across the region as part of the Zebra1 project and we also have a second bid for ‘Zebra 2’ funding submitted to the Department for Transport with Stagecoach and First.

“Not only will they help improve public transport in South Yorkshire, they’ll make a real contribution to us hitting our net zero goals, and making South Yorkshire’s air cleaner. “

Stagecoach Yorkshire Managing Director Matt Kitchin, added: "This marks a huge step towards the future of sustainable travel in South Yorkshire as we await the arrival of the new buses.

“Sustainable forms of public transport are key to reducing congestion and improving air quality across the region and we look forward to these state-of-the-art vehicles encouraging more people to make the switch to bus travel as well as making local air cleaner for all our futures."

The buses will feature a bespoke livery and will be fitted with full electric air conditioning and a bespoke premium passenger saloon for enhanced passenger comfort.

A total of 27 electric buses will be rolled out across South Yorkshire as part of the first stage of ZEBRA.

Images: SYMCA

Read more...

Tuesday, March 21, 2023

News: Supertram announces it won't follow buses with £2 fare extension

By

Discounted fares on the Supertram network in South Yorkshire look unlikely to continue after the end of this month.

An extension to a £2 fare cap was announced recently by the government but it only relates to buses and the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) is yet to announce any further financial support for trams.

Introducing a £2 fare in South Yorkshire (a so called "Mayor's Fare") two months ahead of a national fare cap on journeys "surpassed all expectations" with approaching two million journeys benefiting from the scheme. SYMCA initially set aside £600k as part of bold plans to combat the cost-of-living crisis.

The national scheme began on January 1 but South Yorkshire bus and tram fares have been capped at £2 since November 1. This was set to continue until the end of March 2023.

Last month the government announced plans to provide up to £75m so that bus operators can continue to cap single bus fares outside of London at £2 until the end of June, saving passengers money and encouraging more people back on the bus.

However, Stagecoach, the operator of the Supertam service in Sheffield and Rotherham, has confirmed that from April 1, the £2 single fare cap on tram tickets will end and all adult single fares will revert to their normal prices.

An update from Stagecoach said: "The national single fare cap is funded by Central Government, to allow all bus operators to cap the single fare at £2. The scheme for tram has been funded by the Mayoral Combined Authority, and this extension is ending after 31 March. This means the price of single tickets will revert to their current prices from 1 April."

It means that, short distance singles will be £2.20 and long distance single will be £3. following the January 2023 fare changes, the short distance return has increased from £3.40 to £3.70. Tram Only DayRiders are £5.00 and Tram Only MegaRiders are £18.00 but both can be bought for less on Stagecoach's app.

Advertisement
The take up of the scheme in South Yorkshire has caused budget pressures at the combined authority with the budget for the scheme revised to £700,000, and then £1.1m. By the end of the eight-week scheme (November and December 2022) in South Yorkshire, nearly 1.9m trips were made across bus and tram at a total cost of £810,000. 22% were on the tram.

SYMCA estimates that it would cost £4.7m per year to keep the £2 fare in place. Modelling is underway on a potential increased fare cap (which would require less subsidy) or a single fare structure across the region.

It has been difficult to assess the scheme in South Yorkshire.

An increase in single fare sales has been offset by a reduction in the number of day and weekly tickets sold and measuring an uplift in overall patronage has been difficult given the time of year and Covid restrictions in previous years.

A report states: "The scheme has made (and continues to make) bus and tram travel cheaper for passengers and could be argued as being an effective targeting of subsidy for those that need it. Even though people clearly are benefiting from the scheme, they are likely travelling because they have to (for work) and that a more pronounced reduction in fares of itself would not generate significant patronage growth.

"Whilst the £2 fare cap has clearly been successful in saving passengers money during a cost-of-living crisis ... it is more difficult to demonstrate that such schemes are effective in driving modal shift. For this to be successful, any fares initiative (such as a fare cap, product range simplification, tap on/tap off schemes) need to be complemented by a bus service which is both punctual, reliable and competitive in terms of journey time."

The report adds that, without complimentary measures, a fares subsidy "is unlikely to be a cost-effective approach, unless (as for the Mayor’s fare) it is justified by cost-of-living benefits rather than for the purposes of modal shift and generating patronage growth."

The government has also extended Bus Recovery Grant (BRG) funding through to 30 June 2023 which gives SYMCA policy choices to consider on how it deploys its reserves to best services in the future. The extension of BRG is estimated to leave around £4.54m available from the £7.2m established for the protection of priority bus services.

A recent paper to SYMCA's transport board said that "There remains significant uncertainty as to what DfT [Department for Transport] will do in any further funding settlement beyond 30 June. In the absence of a long-term funding settlement for buses from government, it merely serves to delay the potential significant reduction in bus services when this funding expires."

SYMCA bosses want a longer-term (multi-year) funding settlement for bus to allow sustainable services to be put in place.

Cllr. Chris Read, Co-Chair of the SYMCA Transport and the Environment Board, said: “For many people across the region, public transport is a lifeline to work, to school, and to other services including hospital and doctors appointments. To make our buses sustainable in the long term they must be affordable, with fares that are simple enough for people to understand. That was the plan we agreed with the bus operators and that’s the plan I expect them to stick to. If we can’t make progress on that, it only strengthens the case for re-regulation across South Yorkshire.”

Richard Holden, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport, said: "We are currently working on our plans for when BRG ends on 30 June 2023 and will continue to work with the bus sector, including bus operators and local transport authorities, on the challenges they face."

Images: SYMCA

Read more...

Tuesday, November 1, 2022

News: £2 maximum fares introduced early in South Yorkshire

By

South Yorkshire bus and tram fares have been capped at £2 from today, more than two months ahead of a national £2 cap on bus journeys between January and March.

The government will provide up to £60m across the country with a £600k boost from the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) as part of bold plans to combat the cost-of-living crisis.

The average single fare for a 3-mile journey is estimated at over £2.80. Bus and Supertram journeys which already cost under £2 will not be affected, including 80p Zoom Beyond fares for young people.

£2 adult fares are available on any bus or tram service which starts and ends in South Yorkshire, including services operated by First South Yorkshire, Stagecoach Yorkshire, Supertram, Globe, South Pennine, Hulleys and TM Travel.

Advertisement
South Yorkshire’s Mayor Oliver Coppard, said: “As we head into winter, I know just how many people in South Yorkshire are worrying about feeding their families, heating their homes, and affording the very day to day basics as the cost of living continues to spiral.

“Public transport is part of the solution. That’s why we’re not just introducing the £2 fare cap early here in South Yorkshire, we’re extending it to include trams.

“Because while the Government’s temporary fare cap is welcome, it doesn’t go far enough to support the thousands of people in our region who rely on our buses and tram network. Alongside the Zoom Beyond fares at just 80p for young people, we now have some of the best public transport fares in the country.

“We have a broken public transport network here in South Yorkshire but bit by bit we’re making things better for the travelling public. This is just another step on that journey.”

The government said that it will continue to work closely with bus operators and local authorities and consider future support to help passengers continue accessing reliable and affordable bus services after March.

Mayor Coppard has previously said that the government's "stop-start bus funding fiasco" led to bus operators walking away from some contracts with the SYMCA stepping in and using financial reserves to try and plug the gap. For example, First South Yorkshire had implemented reductions in service in response to a lack of resources in order to ensure delivery.

Images: Travel South Yorkshire

Read more...

Tuesday, October 11, 2022

News: What happens when Stagecoach's contract to run Supertram ends?

By

The current concession for running the Supertram network in Sheffield and Rotherham ends in 2024 and the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) is discussing a future tram operating model.

Opened in 1994, Sheffield's Supertram system cost £240m and now serves major residential and employment sites in Sheffield. A tram-train pilot project brought new vehicles to Rotherham in 2018.

Stagecoach assumed responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the network. Ownership of the asset remained with the authority. The SYMCA board is due to meet next week to discuss a "likely repatriation of operational tram responsibilities."

The MCA wants to establish an arm’s length wholly owned subsidiary company to operate the Supertram system.

The authority had received little interest from the market for a private sector operator to take on the revenue risk and also looked at the possibility of a short term (4/6 years) operating contract with a private sector operator, with the public sector retaining revenue risk.

Hit by reduced patronage during the COVID-19 pandemic and from the closure of parts of the system for renewal works, the network is "currently running at significant losses."

Board papers show that "the costs of supporting tram operations upon the end of the current concession in 2024 have now been modelled into the budget, showing initial subsidy requirements of c. £7m p/a reducing over time. These forecasts remain very sensitive to energy price inflation."

Advertisement
Another issue is that the tram infrastructure and vehicles are nearing the end of their economic life and the renewal programme would see disruption to operations. The MCA has secured c.£100m of capital from DfT to commence this programme of works but a full renewal would cost over £400m.

A previously discussed preferred option included a new fleet of 28 trams, to provide an enhanced service (up to 7.5 trams per hour; further rail and track renewals; improved passenger facilities; the refurbishment and extension of the depot; renewal of control, signalling and communications systems and; renewed and enlarged power supply.

The MCA is in the process of submitting a business case to DfT for further funding.

Back in 2015, Rothbiz revealed that SYPTE still has a deficit of £30.5m on its general reserve budget with a significant part of this relating to capital expenditure incurred by the PTE as part of the construction of the original Sheffield tram network.

South Yorkshire’s Mayor Oliver Coppard said long-term plans for the network’s future must work for the whole of the region:

“Supertram has been part of our region’s fabric for nearly thirty years. It’s iconic to South Yorkshire and plays a critical role in helping us reach our net zero goal. But with that legacy, parts of the system are nearing the end of their design life, and – in the aftermath of the pandemic - passengers are using services differently.

“Our ambitions - for how our communities get to jobs or education, and how they visit family and friends - must work for the whole of our region for a generation to come.

“That is why we are reviewing the funding and future of our region’s tram network. I am excited to propose public sector operation as the next stop on Supertram’s journey. This will help us to develop a long-term approach that integrates Supertram into our wider plans for public transport across South Yorkshire.”

Supertram website

Images: Stagecoach

Read more...

Monday, December 16, 2019

News: The trials of the Sheffield-Rotherham tram-tram

By

Operators have been unable to run any of the innovative tram-trains between Rotherham and Sheffield following an issue with the vehicles.

Tram-trains stopped running on Friday evening due to a "tram engineering issue."

Stadler, the manufacturer of the vehicles, designed to run on both the city's tramlines and the rail network between Sheffield and Rotherham, issued advice on Saturday to operators, Stagecoach, who took the decision to stop running the well-used service.

Funded by the Department for Transport, the industry pilot is a partnership between South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE), Network Rail and Stagecoach Supertram, to test the connectivity and economic potential of the technology to see if it can be used elsewhere.

Earlier in the month, Network Rail said that it had experienced some issues on the tram-train network due to freezing temperatures causing a loss of power.

Chris Gee, head of operations for the North East route at Network Rail, said last week: "We'd like to apologise to Supertram's passengers for the poor levels of tram service delivery on cold mornings.

"We've now made some adjustments to the settings of the overhead line equipment (it was too sensitive) and we are confident that we have resolved the problem.

"We continue to work with Supertram on improving the reliability of the tram-train service."

Advertisement

Stagecoach said last week that the manufacturer of the Citylink fleet was carrying out improvement modifications to the trams, including those vehicles used for the tram-train service, and was expected to be completed on Saturday December 14.

Instead, no tram-trains, have been operating over the weekend.



A new tram-train timetable, with changes to frequency and new later services, was due to begin this week. For example, the last tram-train back from Sheffield was previously at 22:00 but an extra service departing Cathedral at 22:44 is being introduced.

A promotional "After 8" ticket has also been intriduced. For just £2, customers can get unlimited travel from 8pm on Tram Train and Supertram services until the end of service, when boarding at Rotherham Central or Parkgate.

Additionally, the 31 space car park at Parkgate reserved for tram-train users has recently been extended to provide a total of 95 spaces, including two disabled bays and an area allocated for motorcycles.

Supertram website

Images: Stagecoach

Read more...

Friday, October 25, 2019

News: Tram-train marks one million passenger journeys

By

The innovative tram-train service between Rotherham and Sheffield has marked its one millionth passenger journey this month, as the popular service reaches its first-year milestone.

Passengers in South Yorkshire are the first in the country to benefit from the innovative pilot project where special vehicles use pioneering technology to run on both Sheffield's tramlines and the rail network in Rotherham. Funded by the Government, the trial aims to show how similar services can be introduced across the country.

The service has celebrated a 100% customer satisfaction rate and recently won the prestigious Global Light Rail Award for "Team of the Year."

Dan Jarvis, Mayor of the Sheffield City Region, said: "Our region is steeped in rail heritage. We were home to the world-famous Flying Scotsman and Mallard, and now we've successfully pioneered the UK's first tram-train.

"We're proud to be leading the way with light rail innovation, and are now seeing other towns and cities look to us, to use our technology as a blueprint for similar schemes across the UK.

"It's great to see that more than a million people have used the Tram Train over the last year. I look forward to seeing the system continue to thrive, as part of the programme of transport improvements that I’m rolling out to make our network fit for the 21st century."

Advertisement

Funded by the Department for Transport, the industry pilot is a partnership between South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE), Network Rail and Stagecoach Supertram, to test the connectivity and economic potential of Tram Train technology to see if it can be used elsewhere.

Light Rail Minister, Baroness Vere, said: "The award-winning tram-train gives passengers cleaner, more frequent and more reliable journeys across Sheffield and Rotherham.

"This pioneering project has brought together innovation, state-of-the-art technology and our existing infrastructure to give passengers better journeys, and lays the groundwork for more ambitious transport schemes right across the country."

SYPTE Executive Director, Stephen Edwards, added: "While South Yorkshire's award-winning tram-train pilot is a first for the UK, the first year of service has been hugely successful. Both customer satisfaction and passenger numbers are exceeding expectations and we hope that continues.

"Our region is leading the way for tram-train learning and application in the industry. We're proud to deliver this important pilot locally, and to be part of the future opportunities the pioneering technology could provide, both for our region and beyond."

Simon Coulthard, Senior Sponsor for Network Rail, said: "The first year of tram-train has been hugely successful and we are delighted to have played a part in the introduction of this pioneering technology which is better connecting cities and towns across South Yorkshire.

"We look forward to working with our partners to deliver further improvements and providing even more benefits for passengers."

Tim Bilby, Managing Director of Stagecoach Supertram, said: "We are delighted that within the first year over one million passenger journeys have already been made on the tram-train service. Passenger numbers and customer satisfaction have exceeded expectations, proving that Tram Train offers an affordable and efficient way to connect Sheffield City Centre and Rotherham.

"We will continue to work with our project partners to further develop the tram-train service within the region."

Plans to develop the tram-train over the longer term include a 300 space park and ride site for the terminus at Parkgate and a new tram-train stop at Magna, facilitating a new 150 space park and ride site.

Images: Stagecoach

Read more...

Monday, September 23, 2019

News: Forge Island park & ride offer launched

By

Stagecoach Supertram has got Rotherham Council on board to introduce a new parking offer in Rotherham town centre.

Passengers in South Yorkshire are the first in the country to benefit from the innovative tram-train pilot, which entered public service at the end of October 2018. The special vehicles use pioneering technology to run on both Sheffield's tramlines and the rail network in Rotherham.

The new offer is for all day parking at Forge Island Car Park in Rotherham town centre and all day tram travel for just £5.50 per day, allowing passengers to travel to Parkgate or into Sheffield and the rest of the Supertram network.

Advertisement

After parking up, passengers tear their ticket in half and display the top half in their vehicle and show the bottom half to the conductor when buying a discounted tram only dayrider for £2 (usually £4.20).

The offer is for a promotional period only and ends March 2 2020.

Shortly after the launch of the tram-train, Parkgate Shopping retail park in Rotherham warned shoppers about a new Car Park Management Enforcement System restricting parking to five hours.

A new station was built to the rear of Parkgate Shopping and an area of the car park near Matalan was reserved for tram-train users with 31 spaces and no parking charges.

Supertram website

Images: Stagecoach

Read more...

Tuesday, July 16, 2019

News: £408m - the cost of Supertram renewal revealed

By

Transport bosses in the Sheffield city region (SCR) have revealed that the up front capital cost of renewing the existing Supertram network is over £400m.

Rothbiz reported last year on consultation in connection to developing a business case that will be submitted to the Department for Transport to support the funding of any renewal works. As part of this business case all possible options were explored, and consulted on and then a preferred option for the system needs to be submitted.

Now a report to the SCR gives an update on the business case and has set the financial implications for the preferred option of renewing the network and vehicles between 2024-28 at c.£408m.

Opened in 1994, Sheffield's Supertram system cost £240m and now serves major residential and employment sites in Sheffield. A delayed tram-train pilot project brought new vehicles to Rotherham in 2018.

Stagecoach's operating contract runs until 2024. Stagecoach assumed responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the network. Ownership of the asset remains with SYPTE. Early marketing testing has commenced as to the interest from other operating companies who may be considering a future bid to operate the network.

The SCR is prioritising the delivery of a permanent tram-train service between Sheffield and Rotherham and future proofing the existing Supertram network.

The renewal of the asset is also considered essential should the region look to exploit and expand the current network beyond its current operations. The success of the tram-train pilot could indicate that this technology can be applied to extend services to other parts of the region, such as Waverley/AMID, Barnsley or Doncaster.

Advertisement

Following the essential works carried out in 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2018, engineering works are continuing to replace track that was laid in the 1990's but the asset is approaching the end of its economic life. The preferred option for renewal would allow Supertram to operate until at least 2054.

It was expected that following a submission to the Government in October 2019, the renewal project would receive "Programme Entry" by March 2020 with a full business case submitted by April 2022. However the initial targeted pot of transport funding no longer exists.

Tim Taylor, director of customer services at SYPTE, said in the report: "Whilst ongoing general maintenance costs are paid for by the current tram operator (Stagecoach), there is no funding currently in place for the long-term renewal of the system. Investment is therefore needed to allow the Supertram network to operate for at least another 30 years, and central government funding will be required to support this.

"A recent meeting with DfT confirmed that projects such as Supertram renewal do not have a "home" elsewhere within another DfT programme i.e. there is no other existing funding stream which could fund the renewal project.

"It has therefore been agreed that a direct approach to Treasury (supported by DfT), as part of the Comprehensive Spending Review (CSR) process as the most appropriate means of securing the necessary funding. This is in keeping with the approach taken recently by Nexus (the Tyne and Wear Passenger Transport Executive) for the renewal of their Metro train fleet."
Other options have to be considered and these include refurbishing the existing fleet of trams, closing and decommissioning the network and replacing the tram network with a Bus Rapid Transit network.

If the preferred option goes forward, a local contribution of 7-10% (£29-42m) would be expected. This has been a thorny issue for council leaders in Doncaster and Barnsley who haven't wanted to see costs passed on to local authorities.

Supertram website
SYPTE website

Images: Volker Rail

Read more...

Friday, April 12, 2019

News: Satisfaction high amongst tram-train users

By

The innovative tram-train service between Rotherham and Sheffield is certainly on the right track when it comes to passenger satisfaction.

An independent survey by Transport Focus for operator, Stagecoach, has revealed that 100% of respondents are satisfied with the overall journey and journey time on the route which uses the heavy rail line from Meadowhall to Parkgate and the tram network in Sheffield.

Passengers in South Yorkshire are the first in the country to benefit from the innovative pilot project, which entered public service at the end of October. Funded by the Government, the trial uses special vehicles and pioneering technology and aims to show how similar services can be introduced across the country.

It has not been without its problems, from being late and over budget, to a derailment on the first day of services. This week services were suspended for a day due to a vehicle fault which led to the requirement for further checks to be carried out on other Citylink trams.

For the first time the survey asked passengers on the new tram-train service for their views. Satisfaction with the overall journey and journey time on this route was 100%, and 92% were satisfied with the value for money.

Advertisement

Tim Bilby, managing director at Stagecoach Supertram, said: "These survey results are a great endorsement of the commitment and hard work our people at Supertram put into delivering an excellent service for our customers.

"We are particularly pleased that the survey supports our own findings that the new Tram Train service has been extremely popular with users, and it is providing a key new link in South Yorkshire's public transport network.

"We offer high-quality, great value, fast, frequent and punctual tram services which connect easily to other modes of transport and it's great to see that our customers have recognised that.

"People in Sheffield and Rotherham rightly take great pride in their tram network and we work hard every day to deliver the services that they rely on to access employment, education, health and leisure facilities. Along with SYPTE, we are also involved in helping to safeguard the tram network for many years to come through the on-going rail replacement project. However, we are not complacent and will continue to challenge ourselves to do even better."

Tim Taylor, director of customer services at South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE), added: "Supertram is a popular travel option and it's great to have such a positive response to this survey, year-on-year. It's especially encouraging to note, while 41% of the most satisfied respondents have easy access to private transport, they choose to use the tram. We're also particularly pleased with passenger satisfaction on Tram Train services.

"It's reassuring to receive such a good response after the short time services have been running. Together with Stagecoach, we're committed to continuing to make improvements and invest in the future of the network, for even better customer journeys."

Supertram website

Images: SYPTE

Read more...

Friday, October 26, 2018

News: False start for Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train

By

Today was meant to be the first full day of operation for the pioneering tram-train project linking Sheffield and Rotherham but services where suspended until late this morning due to a derailment in Sheffield yesterday afternoon.

Carrying some of the first passengers from Rotherham, one of the newer vehicles, which have been operating on the Supertram network for over a year, was involved in a collision with a lorry at Staniforth Road, Attercliffe. The incident led to gridlock on the roads and services being suspended on Supertram's Yellow route between Cricket Inn Rd and Meadowhall and on the new Tram-train route to Rotherham Central and Parkgate.

The incident came just hours after Government ministers, transport bosses, local councillors and other dignitaries gathered to officially launch the trail project.

Project partners from Stagecoach Supertram, Network Rail, South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE) and the Department for Transport were joined by representatives from local authorities and businesses for the unveiling of a commemorative nameplate by Jo Johnson MP Minister for Rail and the mayor of the Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield Combined Authority, Dan Jarvis.

Passengers in South Yorkshire are the first in the country to benefit from the innovative Tram Train pilot, which entered public service at 09.39 at Sheffield Cathedral. The special tram-type vehicles use pioneering technology to run on both Sheffield's tramlines and the rail network to Rotherham.

Advertisement

Jo Johnson, rail minister said: "The first tram-train journey is a milestone moment that will give commuters cleaner, more frequent and more reliable journeys across Sheffield and Rotherham."

Details of timetables and tickets can be found here.

Cllr. Denise Lelliott, Cabinet Member for Jobs and the Local Economy at Rotherham Council, said: "Today is a very important milestone and it is incredibly exciting to be travelling on this cutting-edge innovative tram vehicle, for the first time to Rotherham town centre and Parkgate."

The SYPTE, Northern Rail and Network Rail have been working together on the pilot project which was first announced in 2009. Securing Government funding, the aim of the project is to help determine whether tram-trains can run in other parts of the country.

A report from the National Audit Office (NAO) revealed that by December 2016, the cost of the works for the project, which had been given an initial estimate of £15m, had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m when you add in the cost of procuring the vehicles.

The project was delayed a number of times as Network Rail got to grips with some of the heavy rail modifications, including power, track modifications, approvals and testing and commissioning.

Rob McIntosh, route managing director at Network Rail, said: "I'd like to thank the people of Sheffield and Rotherham for their patience while we developed, built and tested Tram Train. The project has been a complex one and it is genuinely exciting to be ready to welcome the first passengers on board.

"Tram Train will bring new choices for travellers in this area, supporting jobs and the local economy. It's also important to us at Network Rail as the national infrastructure provider, as it gives us different options when we are looking to improve connections between communities across Britain."

Dan Jarvis, mayor of the Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield Combined Authority, added: "It's good to see schemes such as this transforming our transport network, which has suffered from years of underinvestment. For our economy to grow, and to ensure prosperity for all, we need to have an affordable and well-integrated public transport system that enables people to get to places of work, study and leisure quickly and easily.

"This the first step in transforming our region's transport system and making it fit for the 21st century."

The city region is looking at extending the mass transit network to enhance intra-regional connectivity. Tram, bus rapid transit, rail and highway options are included in new strategies.

The SYPTE is also investigating the feasibility of a tram stop and Park and Ride at Magna in Rotherham.

Supertram website

Images: SYPTE

Read more...

Friday, October 12, 2018

News: Tram-train timetable fills in the gaps

By

Further details of the soon-to-launch tram-train service have been published by operator, Stagecoach Supertram.

Last week, Rothbiz reported that the Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train trial had finally been given a start date for the new innovative vehicles to start taking passengers between Sheffield city centre, Rotherham Central and Parkgate.

The new vehicles, designed to run on both the city's tramlines and the rail network between Sheffield and Rotherham, will begin taking passengers from Thursday October 25. Currently the first passenger service on the launch day is planned to depart Cathedral tram stop at 09:39 and Rotherham Parkgate at 10:09. It should take around 27 minutes to travel the full route.

Three services will operate an hour and will travel on the Supertram network between Sheffield Cathedral and Meadowhall South and utilise a new section of track at Tinlsey, which links the tram line to the rail line. Vehicles will use the national rail network between Tinsley and Rotherham Parkgate via Rotherham Central station.

The first full day of service is on Friday October 26 and details from Stagecoach show that the services will depart Cathedral tram stop at 5:27 and Rotherham Parkgate at 5:29. The last full services of the day depart at 22:31 from Parkgate and 22:00 from Cathedral.

Whilst other Supertram routes are coloured yellow, purple and blue, the tram-train route has not been given a colour. Instead, the new vehicles, which have been in use on the existing network for a year, will show "TT" on the front and rear where you would normally see a colour.

Advertisement

The tram-train services will fill the gaps created at Rotherham Central by the Northern Rail trains running between Sheffield and Rotherham which are skewed and often leave a long gap between services.

For example, on weekday mornings, the service from Rotherham Central to Sheffield will now look like this:

8:02 - Tram-train to Sheffield Cathedral
8:12 - Tram-train to Sheffield Cathedral
8:28 - Train to Sheffield station
8:34 - Tram-train to Sheffield Cathedral
8:44 - Train to Sheffield station
8:57 - Train to Sheffield station

As an example of the prices, passengers will be able to get from Parkgate to Meadowhall for £1.80. A trip further than the FlyDSA Arena is £2.50.

Stagecoach is adding the full tram-train route onto its Tram Only ticket range, such as the £4 dayrider, for a promotional period until April 27 2019.

There are a range of tickets available in both the Sheffield and Rotherham fare zones that allow travel on the Supertram network, tram-train and buses.

Stagecoach has also confirmed that English National Concessionary Travel Scheme (ENCTS) passes are also valid on tram-train but are reminding users that railcards and general rail tickets are not valid for use on any Supertram service.

Stagecoach Supertram website

Images: Stagecoach

Read more...

Tuesday, September 25, 2018

News: £230m needed to fix Supertram

By

Transport bosses in the Sheffield city region (SCR) have revealed that the cost of renewing the existing Supertram network will be around £230m, and some local councils don't want that cost passed on to them.

Rothbiz reported earlier this month that the SCR was developing proposals for a Mass Transit system, identifying a potential network of "key movement corridors" to support growth. At the same time however, it is having to deal with the issue of the existing Supertram network which will require re-railing, new signalling, communications and power supply as well as replacement trams.

Consultation has now begun in connection to developing the business case that will be submitted to the Department for Transport to support the funding of any renewal works. As part of this business case all possible options need to be explored, and consulted on and then a preferred option for the system needs to be submitted.

Options include spending £230m carrying out essential work on the Supertram system when needed, spending a similar amount modernising the system from 2024 with new assests, or decommissioning the tram system replacing it with a dedicated, high quality, bus network from 2024.

Dan Jarvis, mayor of the Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield Combined Authority, said: "For more than 20 years the Supertram has been a fixture within Sheffield and the region and has been making more than 12 million passenger journeys a year.

"We are now working with South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE) to establish what the future of the Supertram system might look like. We want to hear from those people who currently use the Supertram, and those who don't, about what its future should be. I would encourage as many people as possible to have their say."

Advertisement

A funding bid is due for completion and submission to Government in the first half of 2019 but 20% of the costs of the scheme will need to come from the city region.

At a recent meeting of the combined authority, Ros Jones, mayor of Doncaster welcomed the mass transit concept "but asserted the cost of Supertram renewal must be met through grants and fares, and not passed on to the local authorities."

Cllr. Sir Steve Houghton CBE, leader of Barnsley Council, has previously raised concerns over the renewal costs for the Supertram network.

Sheffield Council, whose transport strategy states that Supertram renewal is its "most pressing challenge," has started work on a potential workplace levy, which has been introduced in Nottingham to fund their new tramways, and other transport initiatives.

Opened in 1994, Sheffield's Supertram system cost a reported £240m and now serves major residential and employment sites in Sheffield. A delayed tram-train pilot project is set to bring new vehicles to Rotherham in 2018.

Stagecoach's operating contract runs until 2024. Stagecoach assumed responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the network. Ownership of the asset remains with SYPTE.

In 2014 an unusual accountancy procedure was carried out by the city region to deal with a deficit of £30.5m on its general reserve budget with a significant part of this relating to capital expenditure incurred by the SYPTE as part of the construction of the Sheffield tram network.

A major programme of rail replacement works on the network is currently taking place at an estimated capital cost of £32m.

SYPTE website
Supertram website

Images: Stagecoach Supertram

Read more...

Thursday, September 6, 2018

News: Another £1.2m needed for Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train project

By

The innovative Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train service requires an additional £1.2m to pay for an upgrade at the Supertram depot in Sheffield and cover increased costs.

The much-delayed and vastly over budget pilot project will see vehicles running on both rail and tram networks, using the freight route from Rotherham and then joining the Sheffield Supertram network at Meadowhall South.

It has come in for scrutiny over cost increases and delays, the under-estimation of the scale and complexity of the works, and the risks involved in delivering new technology. Critising the Government and Network Rail, the Public Accounts Committee said that it had all the makings of a "how not to" seminar for future projects.

An earlier report from the National Audit Office (NAO) revealed that by December 2016, the cost of the works for the project, which had been given an initial estimate of £15m, had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m.

Now the South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive's (SYPTE's) capital programme is coming under pressure from further overspending. An additional £1.230m has been identified for the tram-train project.

Advertisement

An update to the Sheffield City Region Combined Authority states: "The estimated final cost of the SYPTE led elements of the project have increased as a result of the proposed installation of an additional gantry at the Nunnery Square tram depot (not in the original project scope, but requested by South Yorkshire Supertram Ltd (SYSL) due to operational difficulties in maintaining a larger fleet of vehicles), increased SYSL operational costs associated with the implementation of tram train, and ongoing prolongation costs incurred as a result of delays in entering into service.

"The revised estimated final cost currently exceeds the budget agreed with DfT in 2013 who are fully funding the project. Discussions are ongoing with DfT regards agreeing a revised budget figure which more realistically reflects the forecast out-turn cost of the project, mindful of the delays and changes since 2013. As a result of these factors, the 2018/19 budget was increased in Q1 to match planned expenditure."

The SYPTE, Northern Rail and Network Rail have been working together on a pilot project which was first announced in 2009.

Network Rail is responsible for the project to modify the national rail infrastructure. SYPTE is responsible for modifying the tramway section and buying new vehicles, while Stagecoach Supertram is testing the vehicles and will run the passenger service.

With agreement from the Department for Transport (DfT), partners developed a business case to combine the tram-train trial with the project to increase capacity on the existing Supertram network in Sheffield. The £18m project to introduce four new tram vehicles secured £12.3m from the DfT in 2011.

SYPTE was awarded an initial £51m from the DfT and had committed some £33m on seven new vehicles. The first vehicle was delivered at the end of 2015, long before the heavy rail track was ready to take passengers to Rotherham.

The NAO report also revealed that Stagecoach Supertram, which holds the concession to operate the tram network until 2024, was awarded £2.5m from the Government after claiming prolongation costs and loss of revenue because of the delays to starting the service.

The 2017-18 SYPTE business plan contained a capital project for the additional vehicles and tram-train worth £52.4m.

Testing and driver training is now underway along the heavy rail line.

Network Rail says that the new tram train route between Parkgate and Sheffield Cathedral is expected to open "by late autumn" 2018.

SYPTE website

Images: Martin Miller / YouTube / SYPTE

Read more...

Monday, September 3, 2018

News: SCR mass transit idea gaining traction despite £200m Supertram bill

By

Transport bosses are looking at extending the mass transit network across the Sheffield city region (SCR) but there's still a pressing need to find £200m for the extensive maintenance that is needed to keep the existing Supertram network on track.

Local provision on rail lines are being examined, including a potential new stop at the Advanced Manufacturing Park (AMP) and Waverley in Rotherham. A further roll-out of tram-train services is being mooted, along with other rapid transit schemes and improved access to stations and new park and ride sites.

The Sheffield City Region (SCR) recently published the first draft of its transport strategy 2018 – 2040 outlining the strategic transport priorities for supporting economic growth. It included the developing idea for a SCR Mass Transit project to enhance intra-regional connectivity.

An update on SCR Mass Transit shows the work being done to identify a potential network of "key movement corridors" to support growth. The work is likely to help provide a case for future transport investment in route specific solutions, including potential tram expansion, bus rapid transit and tram-train.

Rotherham features on a number of priority corridors including the Innovation Corridor, the River Don Corridor and the A631 Corridor.

Advertisement

An update to the SCR Combined Authority, states: "In a recent meeting with senior Department for Transport officials, the establishment of an SCR priority mass transport network to support key policy objectives, was felt to provide a strong strategic narrative for future investment bids made on behalf of the region.

"More detailed development work is required to create the necessary business case documentation to support investment, be that as a single corridor, or a package of connected routes, and would consider the most appropriate modal solution for the corridor in question, be that light rail or an alternate option."

Rothbiz has previously reported on large scale city region transport projects bidding for funding from the Government including the Transforming Cities Fund and the Large Local Major Schemes fund.

Tram, bus rapid transit, rail and highway options are included. Mass transit ideas include a new service to the south east, providing faster connections into Sheffield city centre from Handsworth, Woodhouse and Beighton, possibly with a spur to Aston and Aughton in Rotherham including a new park and ride site to serve the A57.

The main focus is on investigating mass transit opportunities between Sheffield, the Advanced Manufacturing Innovation District (AMID) and Rotherham. Rothbiz recently reported on proposals for another second direct road link between Rotherham and Sheffield.

A study is also being initiated on rail provision on the Sheffield to Lincoln and Rother Valley lines. This will seek to explore options for improved rail connectivity between Sheffield city centre and Waverley and the AMP, Aughton and Killamarsh.

The long-awaited tram-train project should begin to serve Rotherham later this year and transport bosses are looking at its potential for the city region and beyond. Indeed, Transport for the North is studying whether it could provide wider intra-regional connectivity, in order to release capacity on the existing heavy rail network, as a means of potentially enabling Northern Powerhouse Rail connectivity between the SCR and Leeds.

However, transport bosses are at the same time having to deal with the issue of the existing Supertram network which will require re-railing, new signalling, communications and power supply as well as replacement trams.

It is forecast that the costs of renewing the Supertram asset will be in excess of £200m. A funding bid is due for completion and submission to Government in the first half of 2019 but 20% of the costs of the scheme will need to come from the city region.

The recently published Sheffield Transport Strategy states: "Our most pressing challenge is that the Supertram system requires extensive maintenance. Vehicles and infrastructure are reaching the end of their economic life and require extensive maintenance, only affordable with central Government support.

"Should the city fail to secure funding for these maintenance works, the failure of Supertram would be a major setback, ruling out future tram extensions and posing challenges as to how (or if) people currently travelling by tram would travel into the city and undermining the improvements in connectivity between Sheffield and Rotherham afforded by tram-train. Avoiding this is our first public transport priority."

Stagecoach's operating contract runs until 2024. Stagecoach assumed responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the network. Ownership of the asset remains with SYPTE.

Sheffield Council has also started work on a potential workplace levy, which has been introduced in Nottingham to fund their new tramways, and other transport initiatives.

Images: SYPTE / SCR

Read more...

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

News: Tram-train spotted in Rotherham

By

You may have thought that the day may never come but the Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train project is moving ever closer to servicing Rotherham as the innovative new vehicles are now being tested in the borough.

First mentioned in 2009, the now £100m+ project will see vehicles running on both rail and tram networks, using the freight route from Rotherham and then joining the Sheffield Supertram network at Meadowhall South. The service will run between Parkgate and Sheffield Cathedral.

Work was completed in April on overhead power lines in the Tinsley area to connect the Supertram and Network Rail routes. The new Citylink vehicles, which have been operating on the regular Supertram timetable from October 2017 to support the existing Stagecoach service, were tested on the heavy rail network overnight in May.

Daylight testing and driver training is now underway along the Network Rail line and, as the video below shows, vehicles have been spotted at the new lowered platforms at Rotherham Central station in addition to testing out the new sidings and turnback at Parkgate.

Advertisement

The project has been delayed a number of times as Network Rail struggled to get to grips with some of the heavy rail modifications, including power, track modifications, approvals and testing and commissioning. The lead contractor, Carillion, entered administration at the start of 2018.

New vehicles will eventually run between Sheffield city centre and Parkgate via Meadowhall South and Rotherham town centre. A revised construction programme was announced last year that points to infrastructure being completed during Summer 2018.

Network Rail says that the new tram train route is expected to open "by late autumn" 2018.

With funding from the Government, the scheme is set to run for two years with a view to permanent operation. It is the first of its kind in the UK and if it is successful, it opens the way for tram trains to be introduced in other parts of the country.

A report from the National Audit Office (NAO) criticised the management of the trial when it revealed that by December 2016, the cost of the works, which had been given an initial estimate of £15m, had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m.

The Government's Public Accounts Committee looked at the issues of cost increases and delays, the under-estimation of the scale and complexity of the works, and the risks involved in delivering new technology. It said that the project had all the makings of a "how not to" seminar for future projects.

Supertram website
SYPTE website

Images: Martin Miller / YouTube

Read more...

Monday, May 14, 2018

News: Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train going live

By

Work continues to progress on the innovative Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train project which has moved into the final stages of construction.

New vehicles will eventually run between Sheffield city centre and Parkgate via Meadowhall South and Rotherham town centre.

Following the collapse of the lead contractor, Carillion, Network Rail has confirmed that the "project remains on schedule to deliver the infrastructure to our partners in South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive and Supertram to allow driver training to begin while the final infrastructure work and testing is completed this Summer."

With funding from the Government, the £100m scheme is set to run for two years with a view to permanent operation. It is the first of its kind in the UK and if it is successful, it opens the way for tram trains to be introduced in other parts of the country.

Network Rail has struggled to get to grips with the upgrades needed to the heavy rail sections of the route, and having originally being delayed, work was completed in April on overhead power lines in the Tinsley area to connect the Supertram and Network Rail routes.

The new vehicles have been spotted on the heavy rail network at night.

The Department for Transport (DfT) is the client in the project and South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE) is responsible for the delivery of all of the light rail modifications, rail replacement and procurement of the vehicles. Network Rail is separately responsible to DfT to deliver the heavy rail modifications required for the project.

Following the liquidation of Carillion, New Civil Engineer reported that the Network Rail contract for the project was picked up by the Rail Electrification Alliance, a JV between Network Rail, VolkerRail, Siemens, J Murphy and Sons, Jacobs and TSP.

Advertisement

Community safety manager at Network Rail, Vicki Beadle, has been visiting local schools to deliver the safety message. She said: "Many people – and not just children – think that the overhead line only carries electricity when trains, or Tram Trains, are coming through. That's simply not true. The wires are electrified all the time and these ones carry 750 volts. We don't want anyone's life to be irreversibly changed by coming into contact with that so we are making our message clear – the electricity is always on, so stay off the tracks."

Testing of the vehicles, which have been in use on the existing network in Sheffield since September, is taking place and further work includes the construction of low level platforms at Rotherham Central and a new stop at Parkgate.

Beadle added: "Regular tram users will be used to crossing directly between platforms, across the tramlines. We need to remind people that this simply isn't safe on the rail network as a train could be coming through on the other lines and the driver can’t swerve and won't be able to brake in time. Please remember to use the footbridge if you need to change platforms."

A report from the National Audit Office (NAO) criticised the management of the trial when it revealed that by December 2016, the cost of the works, which had been given an initial estimate of £15m, had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m.

The Government's Public Accounts Committee looked at the issues of cost increases and delays, the under-estimation of the scale and complexity of the works, and the risks involved in delivering new technology. It said that the project, first mentioned in 2009, had all the makings of a "how not to" seminar for future projects.

Network Rail website
SYPTE website

Images: Network Rail

Read more...

Friday, December 15, 2017

News: Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train pilot - "how not to run a rail project"

By

The Government and Network Rail have come in for more criticism over the innovative Sheffield-Rotherham tram-train service that is scheduled to reach the borough in 2018.

The Public Accounts Committee looked at the issues of cost increases and delays, the under-estimation of the scale and complexity of the works, and the risks involved in delivering new technology. It said that it had all the makings of a "how not to" seminar for future projects.

The committee is made up of MPs and scrutinises the value for money of public spending and generally holds the Government and its civil servants to account for the delivery of public services.

The inquiry follows on from a July report from the National Audit Office (NAO) that revealed that by December 2016, the cost of the works for the project, which had been given an initial estimate of £15m, had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m.

The business case for the proposed scheme was based on the benefits to local transport users, such as reduced journey times. The project's benefit-cost ratio (BCR) of 1.0 fell into the Department for Transport's (DfT's) "low" value-for-money category. As costs increased, this slipped further to 0.31, in terms of the local public transport case.

The NAO report revealed that the pilot project was close to being cancelled altogether as costs spiraled, but it was saved, mainly due to the interest in the development of further tram-train schemes with greater potential elsewhere in the country.

Advertisement

Meg Hillier MP, chair of the Public Accounts Committee, said: "This project promised great benefits for passengers and, importantly, a potential model for similar schemes in cities such as Manchester, Cardiff and Glasgow. Instead the reality is another rail project with all the makings of a "how not to" seminar for senior civil servants.

"This pilot was trialling technology new to the UK, yet neither Network Rail nor the Department for Transport properly considered the high level of risk and uncertainty.

"Unrealistic costings went unchallenged, resulting in an initial budget of £15mn spiralling to some £75m. There have been long delays, and it is still not clear how, or even if, the experience of running this pilot will reduce the costs and improve delivery of any future tram-train schemes.

"Not for the first time, we heard evidence intended to reassure Parliament and the public that lessons learned on this project will ensure the failings identified will not arise again.

"We will be expecting Government to back this up with a meaningful review of the way it manages such projects, from calculating cost estimates through to transparently evaluating results.

"Actions speak louder than words and on behalf of taxpayers we will, if necessary, recall witnesses responsible for current and future projects and hold them to account for their performance."

First mentioned in 2009, the project has always been considered a pilot scheme, the first of its kind in the UK, and was only approved on an exceptional basis.

The DfT is the client in the project, with South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE) responsible for the delivery of all of the light rail modifications, rail replacement and procurement of the vehicles. Network Rail is separately responsible to DfT to deliver the heavy rail modifications required for the project.

Since 2016, Network Rail has achieved a number of milestones, including installing new track at Tinsley, the power supply and a tram-train platform at Rotherham Parkgate and work on the College Road bridge at Rotherham Central. It also said that it has changed the way it is managing the project.

The innovative CityLink vehicles are now in service, but only on the existing Supertram network in Sheffield. They will eventually run as tram-trains between Sheffield city centre and Parkgate via Meadowhall South and Rotherham town centre, sometime in 2018.

DfT website
Network Rail website

Images: SYPTE / Network Rail

Read more...

Thursday, September 14, 2017

News: Tram train goes into passenger operation

By

The first "citylink" tram train vehicle will go into passenger operation this week, but only on the existing tram network in Sheffield as the delayed scheme will not begin operating to Rotherham until next year.

First mentioned in 2009, the project will see vehicles running on both rail and tram networks, using the freight route from Rotherham and then joining the Sheffield Supertram network at Meadowhall South.

The vehicles arrived in the city region in 2016. Seven Citylink Class 399 vehicles have been delivered and are stabled at Stagecoach Supertram's Nunnery Square depot in Sheffield. Of these seven, three will run on the Supertram network and three will run as Tram Trains between Sheffield City Centre and Parkgate in 2018. One vehicle will be used as a spare.

Testing and driver training has been underway and today passengers will be the first in Great Britain to travel on the innovative tram vehicle when it goes into operation from Meadowhall.

With funding from the Government, the £100m scheme is set to run for two years with a view to permanent operation. It is the first of its kind in the UK and if it is successful, it opens the way for tram trains to be introduced in other parts of the country.

Advertisement

To celebrate the occasion, operator, Stagecoach Supertram and South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE) will be naming the first tram after The Sheffield Children's Hospital Charity's mascot, Theo. The hospital's CEO, John Somers will accompany Theo to a naming ceremony at Stagecoach's depot at Nunnery Square, before the tram continues to Meadowhall. They will all be joined by Transport Minister Paul Maynard MP.

The tram will also be in service on Sunday September 17 as a special charity service with Supertram staff collecting donations for The Children's Hospital Charity once again.

A report from the National Audit Office revealed that by December 2016, the cost of infrastructure works on the project had quadrupled to £75.1m, pushing the overall cost of the scheme over £100m. Network Rail came in for criticism over initial assumptions and assessments.

The report also showed that Stagecoach Supertram, which holds the concession to operate the tram network until 2024, has been awarded £2.5m from the Government after claiming prolongation costs and loss of revenue because of the delays to starting the tram train service.

Supertram website
SYPTE website

Images: SYPTE


Read more...
Members:
Supported by:
More news...

  © Blogger template Newspaper III by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP